Showing posts with label Pirelli. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Pirelli. Show all posts

Sunday, 12 January 2014

Autosport International Show 2014 - Plenty of cars, plenty of colour

By Simon Wright - Follow me on Twitter @Siwri88

The motorsport season officially began for many budding fans of the sport this weekend. Some of the finest and colourful models were on display to the public for the 2014 Autosport International Show.

The annual exhibition, once again in Birmingham’s vast and spacious LG Arena or in the NEC as it might be better known saw some of last season’s cars pitted together with new designs for 2014 and echoes of a great past. As ever I made the trip on Saturday, 11 January for the 11th successive year. Leaving Birmingham, I couldn’t say I had been shortchanged in going.

The Live Action Arena produced the usual blend of thrills and spills. Hosted by Sky Sports F1 commentator David Croft and Pollyanna Woodward from Channel 5 programme The Gadget Show, the content was diverse from stunt driving to BRISCA racing and a display by the six contenders nominated for the prestigious McLaren Autosport Young Driver award. After a slow burning beginning with a fair amount of talking from the hosts, the action hotted up in the second part of the programme with the Freestyle Motocross at the end of the performance a definite highlight. Even if you left feeling a bit disappointed with the general content, everyone who had tickets for the arena would have to admit it was worth the value to see these experts in action.

One of the main selling points of the 2014 show was a grand exhibition of cars to celebrate the life and career of British racing driver John Surtees. This year marks the 50th anniversary of his 1964 Grand Prix championship triumph with Ferrari and the great man was in attendance all weekend to reminisce about the past and share his thoughts on the current breed of driver. Among the exhibits of a man who is still the only individual to win major world championships on two and four wheels were his F1 winning car from 1964 which won races in Italy and on Germany’s daunting Nurburgring circuit and the 1970 Team Surtees TS7 which made its debut on home soil at Brands Hatch in that year. I was surprised with how good the quality of this part of the exhibition was and it was a fitting mark to a man who I think is sadly often overlooked for his achievements in British and world motorsport.

As ever, the Autosport Stage in association with KX Momentum Energy Drink was a place for the stars to be interviewed with some lucky fans winning tickets to the 2014 British Grand Prix for testing and challenging questions. It was short of mega superstars from Formula One although respected commentator Martin Brundle was a frequent visitor to the stage throughout the weekend. New Sauber driver Adrian Sutil was there too but only for the Sunday of the exhibition and Max Chilton was the other Grand Prix driver in attendance. After a 100 per cent finishing record in his maiden season in the elite, Chilton was confirmed this weekend as a Marussia driver once again for 2014. The show must carry on but there was also a small box for guests to come and leave messages of support for Michael Schumacher following his recent skiing accident which has left him fighting for his life. It was a nice gesture but I was personally disappointed there were no cards or paper left out for guests to fill out and post in the box. It was a good thing I brought pen and paper to the event. If you didn’t and wanted to leave a message for Schumacher, I’d imagine you’d be leaving a little bit annoyed.

The F1 Racing Grid was the last chance to see cars in their V8 guise
The F1 Racing Grid returned for another year and was a real highlight of this year’s proceedings. It was the last time that visitors will get to see the F1 cars in the previous regulations of the V8 era (Lotus Renault car pictured above). 2014 brings a new raft of technical changes including the return of turbocharged power and a switch to V6 units. There was easier access to the cars throughout apart of course from when top guests arrived to be interviewed. Sky commentator Brundle admitted in one of his many exchanges this weekend that “all bets are off for the 2014 season.”

It is fair to say that Pirelli attracted some difficult publicity in 2013, most notably when the Italian manufacturer’s tyres kept blowing up during the British Grand Prix at Silverstone last June. Question the tyre construction if you want but don’t question the staff who work hard for them and the options open to fans for their stand. The racing simulator and driver reactions game were both back – both priced but at prices that wouldn’t leave anyone out of the market. I tried the driver reactions twice during the day and got a high score of 37 and an average in six 30-second stints of 33. I was pretty happy with that and it does get the adrenaline going. Those who don’t fancy a lengthy jog should try this. I must also credit Pirelli for the neat presentation of their display.

There was a lovely collection of cars from the likes of Caterham, Porsche, Ford and Subaru and the Asian manufacturer was also highly prevalent at the Wales Rally GB display. Celebrating its 70th anniversary in 2014, three classic Impreza models were on show in Birmingham, including the late Colin McRae’s winning car from 1997 and the machinery that took Richard Burns to his WRC title four years later (pictured below). This was during a golden period for rallying which might have a brighter future following this weekend’s announcement that it has been added to the portfolio of events in 2014 to be live on BT Sport. It was another polished display but I for one would have liked to have seen two or three more manufacturers represented on this stand.

Richard Burns' 2001 WRC world championship car was a highlight
Lastly the pick of the exhibition this year was the Dunlop BTCC section. It looked superb, slick and stunning and you were able to get close to the drivers too. A whole host of the BTCC class were there which included a couple of mass signing sessions during the weekend. Those in attendance included defending champion Andrew Jordan, 2012 title winner Gordon Shedden, seasoned campaigners Matt Neal and Jason Plato and the popular Rob Austin. I was lucky enough to get autographs from many of the drivers and had a brief conversation with Neal, telling him I liked the look of the new Honda Civic that he and Shedden will be driving in the upcoming campaign. It was great to see the camaraderie between the drivers and I’m a huge fan of the championship. With F1 becoming more sanitised (especially when you think of the double points decider gimmick in Abu Dhabi), I will even go as far as saying the Touring Cars is my favourite motorsport and the championship I’m looking forward to the most in 2014.

So there you have it, another year and another exhibition at the NEC comes to an end. Autosport International continues to drive the crowds through every year and will be back next year hoping for another special exhibition. Having been to 11 of these now, I would happily admit that I have been to years where I enjoyed it more (2008 and 2012) being standouts but it was an improvement on last year and well worth going.

What will happen in the motorsport season in 2014? Well like Martin Brundle, all bets are off and I won’t be making any predictions. I’m sure though the sport in general will create many more headlines and talking points over the course of this calendar year.

Sunday, 1 December 2013

F1 2013 - Sebastian crushes the opposition

By Simon Wright - Follow me on Twitter @Siwri88


One man and one team completely dominated the 2013 Formula One World Championship as the invincible Sebastian Vettel (pictured) stormed to a fourth successive title, breaking more records in the process. His 13 wins in the season equalled Michael Schumacher’s mark from 2004 and he strung together nine successive victories, matching the record set by Alberto Ascari all the way back in 1952/1953. He simply crushed the opposition and proved why he is the best – his points total would have won the constructors’ championship on its own.

Sadly while Vettel and his Red Bull Racing team deserve all the plaudits for their almost unbeatable campaign, the spectacle disappointed. Races failed to live up to their potential, with tyres often dictating pace and putting safety at high risk. TV viewing figures dropped considerably as the season progressed and off-track politics took centre stage with team orders, illegal tyre tests, unpaid drivers and tyres blowing up left, right and centre often taking the headlines over quality driving and wheel-to-wheel combat racing. F1 2013 won’t be remembered as a classic season after the epics of recent years, especially 2007, 2008 and 2012.

Multi-21 madness in Malaysia
2013 would be the driest F1 season since 1987 but it started with a downpour in Australia that delayed the majority of qualifying until race morning. Vettel started the season with pole position but he was beaten into third place in the race itself as the Australian Grand Prix became an intriguing battle of tactics and playing the waiting game. It was the Lotus of Kimi Raikkonen who eventually prevailed, with his two-stop strategy outsmarting the three-stop efforts from Vettel and Ferrari’s Fernando Alonso who chased Raikkonen home in second. Lewis Hamilton finished fifth on his Mercedes bow and Adrian Sutil had a strong return after a year out of the sport, leading a portion of the race on his way to seventh. It was round one to Raikkonen and Lotus but that was as good as it was going to get for this relationship.

A week later in Malaysia, the word Multi-21 became the talking point in the F1 paddock. After a wet start, Mark Webber had gained the upper hand on team-mate Vettel as he had pitted earlier for slick tyres. Vettel wasn’t happy with this and despite being issued instructions to hold station behind the Aussie; he ignored team orders and proceeded to race Webber in a ferocious battle with 10 laps to go. Vettel eventually got past around the outside of turn four and went on to controversially win the race. His actions though were disapproved by his team and angered many fans and F1 journalists. A more ruthless character had emerged and his relationship with Webber all but broke down after this incident. The Mercedes duo of Hamilton and Nico Rosberg finished third and fourth, although Lewis made an embarrassing pitstop in the box of his old team McLaren during the race! Alonso crashed out on lap two after his front wing failed following damage on the opening circuit.

The Red Bull team orders row rumbled on into China, with Vettel defending his actions in a highly charged press conference pre-event, accusing Webber of not helping his title bid at the end of the previous season in Brazil and indicating: “Bottom line was, I was faster, I was racing, I passed him, I won.” For once, Red Bull didn’t have the ultimate pace with Sebastian having a quiet weekend to finish fourth from a lowly ninth on the grid. Webber had a miserable time as he was disqualified from qualifying as he couldn’t provide a fuel sample, then he collided with Jean-Eric Vergne in the race and later lost a right-rear wheel, finishing his afternoon prematurely. Alonso won comfortably from Raikkonen and pole-sitter Hamilton. Jenson Button was an encouraging fifth for McLaren but already, their season looked doomed with an uncompetitive car that left them scrapping for a distant fifth in the constructors’ championship.

The final event of the early season flyaways occurred in Bahrain and it was a case of déjà vu to the 2012 race. The podium was exactly the same as Vettel became the first repeat winner of the campaign. The Lotus pair of Raikkonen and Romain Grosjean completed the rostrum. There were more team squabbles in the desert and this time it was at McLaren. After being accused of lacking aggression by team principal Martin Whitmarsh in his first three races for his new team, Sergio Perez responded with some robust driving which led to contact with team-mate Button and Jenson to shout on the radio: “He’s hit me up the back, calm him down.” Perez finished a strong sixth, while Button faded to tenth. Paul di Resta had a fabulous weekend, qualifying fifth and matching his best ever career result with fourth for Force India.

After a DRS failure wrecked his race chances in Sakhir, Alonso was slightly on the backfoot as the Grand Prix circus returned to Europe. His response was magnificent on his home turf in Barcelona. Despite lining up fifth, the Spaniard produced a breathtaking double pass on Raikkonen and Hamilton around the outside of turn three on the first lap and managed the high degradation Pirelli tyres perfectly to win in Spain for the third time in his career. Raikkonen split the Ferrari’s, as Felipe Massa finished a fine third from ninth on the grid. Pirelli were left under the microscope with tyre delaminations for di Resta in practice and Vergne in the race, following three previous incidents in Bahrain. Mercedes had a nightmare on Sunday afternoon with a lack of tyre grip. Despite locking out the front row, Rosberg and Hamilton slipped horribly back to sixth and twelfth. The next storm was about to brew.

It emerged on race morning in Monte Carlo that Mercedes had done a three-day tyre test after the race at the Circuit de Catalunya with Pirelli, using their race drivers and in its 2013 car. Both Red Bull and Ferrari made an official protest against the team which would lead to a hearing before the British Grand Prix at the FIA Court of Appeal. In Monaco, Mercedes managed their tyre wear life and Rosberg drove exceptionally to win around the streets from his third straight pole position. He achieved the victory on the 30th anniversary of his father’s victory for Williams at the same event. It would have been a 1-2 but for a misjudgement behind the Safety Car from Hamilton which dropped him behind the Red Bull cars and ruing his error as he finished fourth. There was a red flag during the race after Pastor Maldonado crashed heavily at Tabac following contact with Max Chilton which moved the trackside barriers onto the racing line. Maldonado was unhurt and so was Massa, who had two almost identical accidents in two days at Ste Devote, the second in the race.

Tragedy in Canada
The Canadian Grand Prix often delivers excitement but that wasn’t the case in 2013 with the race turning into a dour affair. Vettel took pole and won at a canter, with Alonso making up for his lacklustre seventh place finish in Monaco to finish second holding off Hamilton in a late tussle. Rookie Valtteri Bottas made the F1 fraternity sit up and take notice in qualifying as he made the most of mixed conditions to start a fabulous third in an uncompetitive Williams. The event was overshadowed though by a tragic accident after the race that claimed the life of track marshal Mark Robinson. He was run over by a moving crane as Esteban Gutierrez’s Sauber was being recovered from turn two. His death was the first at an event since the 2001 Australian Grand Prix.

Regular tyre blowouts ruined the British Grand Prix at Silverstone
After the tragic events of Montreal, Formula One was lucky to have no more injuries at Silverstone. Tyres had controlled the season and the whole issue about their reliability blew up dramatically as the British Grand Prix turned into an farce. Six drivers including early race leader Hamilton, Vergne (pictured) and Massa had tyre blowouts, whilst the most terrifying incident was a failure for Perez that had Alonso cheating serious injury as he ducked out of the McLaren’s slipstream at 180mph. It marred another great drive from Rosberg who held off a charging Webber to claim his second victory in three events. Webber had taken the opportunity earlier in the weekend to announce his retirement from the sport at the end of the season. Vettel chalked up a rare DNF when his gearbox broke with 11 laps to go; to the delight of many of the British fans while Hamilton recovered brilliantly from his early tyre failure to finish fourth.

In the aftermath of the Silverstone debacle, the blame game began with Pirelli accusing the Northamptonshire circuit of ‘high kerbs’ and the teams for ignoring their tyre pressure recommendations. Ultimately the Young Drivers Test became a three-day tyre test at the home of British motorsport with race drivers included and the 2012 structure returned in a mix with the 2013 compounds. It would have a major impact on the destiny of where the championship would go from this point onwards. Mercedes weren’t at this test as they had been banned by the WMSC following the Barcelona tyre test against regulations in May.

Vettel started his march to the title again with a hard-fought win at his home event at the Nurburgring, his first win on home soil. The Lotus drivers of Raikkonen and Grosjean pushed him hard as they completed the podium picture after three difficult events for Lotus that had seen them pick up just 13 points. There was another scary incident when a wheel detached itself from Webber’s car in the pits and struck an FOM cameraman in the back; knocking him to the ground and sending him to hospital with severe bruising. Webber fought back to seventh after a mid-race Safety Car for Jules Bianchi’s Marussia that caught fire, then rolled back across the track, almost taking out race leader Vettel in another bizarre incident.

Hamilton’s emotional dedication
Lewis Hamilton's only 2013 win came at Budapest in a tough year
The final race before the summer break was the Hungarian Grand Prix at Budapest and it is becoming Hamilton’s happy hunting ground. The Brit (pictured) recorded his fourth victory at the Hungaroring from pole position, his first for Mercedes. It was an emotional success for the 2008 world champion who had to deal with yet another painful breakup in his relationship with X-Factor judge Nicole Scherzinger in the summer. Hamilton dedicated the win to his former girlfriend but it seems like this separation is for good. Raikkonen came second, while Vettel had to settle for third, delayed in traffic behind Jenson Button after the first round of pitstops. After finishing an uncompetitive fifth, Alonso received a rebuke from Ferrari president Luca di Montezemolo when he suggested he would like “someone else’s car” for his birthday. It suggested things weren’t rosy in the Ferrari camp anymore; with noises being made of a possible move to Red Bull for 2014.

The Austrian team based in Milton Keynes though would eventually choose Daniel Ricciardo to be Webber’s successor for next season after negotiations with Raikkonen’s management broke down. Four weeks after Budapest, F1 returned with a belting qualifying session at the daunting Spa-Francorchamps circuit in Belgium. A gamble on slick tyres in Q1 saw both Marussia cars and Giedo van der Garde’s Caterham escape the session, whilst di Resta almost got pole after a well-timed lap in the dry part of Q3. Unfortunately for the Scot he was bumped down to fifth as the weather changed again in the dying stages and Hamilton achieved his fourth successive pole. However that was as good as it got for the Brit’s season. Vettel overwhelmed him into Les Combes on the first circuit of the race and drove into the distance, with Alonso second and the Mercedes man third. Raikkonen’s run of 27 consecutive points finishes ended with a brake problem on his Lotus just after half-distance.

By now, Alonso was the only driver who looked remotely close to challenging Vettel should his form suddenly capitulate. That hope ended at the final European event of the season at Monza. On a track that has normally exposed Red Bull’s weaknesses, Vettel was fastest in every single session and won the race at a stroll. Alonso did manage to spilt the Red Bulls, helped by a demon overtake on Webber in the early laps. Nico Hulkenberg reminded everyone of his quality after he qualified third for Sauber then finished a strong fifth in the race. Raikkonen missed out on points again following contact with his Perez on the first lap, while Hamilton rescued ninth place from a dire weekend that included elimination in Q2.

Flaming Webber
Formula One’s worst kept secret was revealed to the public between Italy and Singapore, as Ferrari confirmed Raikkonen was returning to the team for 2014 alongside Alonso. Kimi stated it was to do with money, suggesting there were severe financial issues at Lotus. The news meant Felipe Massa’s eight-year stay at Maranello was drawing to a conclusion but he would be announced as a Williams driver for 2014 before the season’s end. Under the lights at the Marina Bay, Vettel made it three wins in a row at the event, with Raikkonen defying the aggravation of an old back injury in qualifying to finish a fine third from 13th on the grid. Webber retired on the last lap with a gearbox problem and then copped a 10-place grid penalty for getting a lift back to the pits on the back of Alonso’s car on the slowing down lap.

Mark Webber can only watch as his Red Bull burns in Korea
It was now a question of when, rather than if Vettel would become champion once again. He reigned supreme as ever in Korea which arguably was a contender for race of the season. While he dominated, team-mate Webber went up in flames – quite literally (pictured). He was clobbered by Adrian Sutil after a mid-race Safety Car period. The connection with the Force India cracked an oil line and it wasn’t long before the back of the car went up in flames pretty spectacularly. The appearance of a fire truck before the Safety Car returned to the circuit saw the organisers get a hefty slap on the wrist afterwards. The Lotus pair of Raikkonen and Grosjean finished second and third, while Hulkenberg produced the drive of the season to come home fourth, keeping both Hamilton and Alonso at bay for the majority of the race due to his car’s strong straight-line speed.

The only time Vettel looked like he might be beaten in the run-in was at the Japanese Grand Prix. Romain Grosjean and Lotus asked a serious question which was responded in confident style by Red Bull. Webber had edged into pole position after a KERS problem for Vettel in qualifying but both were beaten off the line by a lightning Grosjean. Slight contact with Vettel’s car punctured a tyre on Hamilton’s Mercedes and ended his day early. The Lotus man kept Vettel behind for nearly 40 laps but eventually had to give best to both RBR machines. His third place though was richly deserved. Alonso came fourth followed by Raikkonen and Hulkenberg. The paddock was stunned though at Suzuka by the tragic death of ex-Marussia test driver Maria de Vilota who had been found dead in a Seville hotel as her injuries from the dreadful testing accident suffered last summer ultimately proved fatal.

Vettel does it in style
Fourth place in Japan for Alonso had kept the championship mathematically alive but all Vettel needed on the sport’s last visit to India for a year was a top five finish. This he achieved in style with a sixth straight victory and sealing both a fourth successive drivers title for himself and constructors championship for the team. Webber was nailed on for a certain second place until an alternator issue grounded his car on lap 40. That allowed Nico Rosberg to finish a strong second but some half a minute behind and Grosjean charged through from 17th to take third again. That was only after a near altercation with team-mate Raikkonen in the closing laps that forced Lotus chief race engineer Alan Permane to leave some brutal words in Kimi’s radio – shouting: “Kimi, get out of the f####ng’ way.” Afterwards, Vettel treated the Indian fans to some doughnuts in his car, before bowing down to his monster of a chassis and leaving it on the start-finish straight. Rather than accept the reasoning for this, the FIA fined the team and driver to the chagrin of many paddock insiders.

Following the stiff row that broke out at Lotus after India, Raikkonen almost didn’t turn up in Abu Dhabi and only arrived at the last minute to drive. He expressed his dissatisfaction to the media and claimed that he hadn’t been paid a single euro for the season. He threatened to go on strike but an agreement was eventually reached for his rightful salary to be paid. In the UAE, Kimi was thrown out of qualifying for a technical infringement then hit van der Garde on the first corner, retired, left for the airport and wasn’t to be seen for the rest of the year as he underwent a back operation shortly afterwards. For the record in a forgettable race, Vettel won by nearly half a minute from Webber, Rosberg, Grosjean and Alonso.

If Abu Dhabi had been a tedious race, the spectacle in Austin, Texas was one of the most boring events of the past 20 years in the sport. Overtaking was limited, Pirelli brought tyres that were way too conservative and action on-track was non-existent. Vettel became the first man to win eight races in a row in a season, while a fast start from Grosjean saw him beat Webber to second and continue his rise in reputation. Valtteri Bottas scored the first championship points of his career with a fine eighth place in a desperate year for Williams.

So it came to an end in Brazil and it was a predictable end to the championship. Vettel won the race again to ensure he remained unbeaten at any event since late July. However the day wasn’t about him equalling records. It was about Webber, who bowed out of the sport by taking off his crash helmet on the slowing down lap and a pirouette on the rostrum as he finished his career with second place in the race and third in the championship. Massa might have made the podium in his final Ferrari race until he collected a drive-through penalty that left him screaming on the radio: “Unbelievable, unbelievable decision FIA!” With Hamilton also receiving a similar sanction for needless contact with Bottas on lap 47, Alonso took the final podium of the season. Jenson Button offered McLaren a crumb of comfort with fourth place and Perez came through from 19th to sixth but had already been fired for next season.

The racing quality in 2013 was uninspiring and the results fairly predictable but no-one can take away Sebastian Vettel’s amazing achievements. He now has to be ranked alongside the likes of Fangio, Schumacher and Senna with his record-breaking campaign.

2014 brings a whole new raft of changes. We say goodbye to Mark Webber, Ross Brawn, probably Paul di Resta, the Indian Grand Prix and V8 engines and say hello to the V6 turbo engine, bigger KERS units, Dane rookie Kevin Magnussen at McLaren, Daniel Kvyat at Toro Rosso and a new race in Russia as well as a welcome return to the calendar for the Austrian Grand Prix. Let’s hope this mixture will shake up the competition and make 2014 a more memorable championship than the one served up in 2013. This year will be known as the year where Vettel crushed the opposition. Enjoy next season and for the last time writing for Formula One on Viewing Perspectives, thank you for reading and goodbye.

FINAL STANDINGS
Drivers’ Championship: 1. Sebastian Vettel 397, 2. Fernando Alonso 242, 3. Mark Webber 199, 4. Lewis Hamilton 189, 5. Kimi Raikkonen 183, 6. Nico Rosberg 171, 7. Romain Grosjean 132, 8. Felipe Massa 112, 9. Jenson Button 73, 10. Nico Hulkenberg 51, 11. Sergio Perez 49, 12. Paul di Resta 48, 13. Adrian Sutil 29, 14. Daniel Ricciardo 20, 15. Jean-Eric Vergne 13, 16. Esteban Gutierrez 6, 17. Valtteri Bottas 4, 18. Pastor Maldonado 1

Constructors’ Championship: 1. Red Bull Racing 596, 2. Mercedes GP 360, 3. Ferrari 354, 4. Lotus 315, 5. McLaren 122, 6. Force India 77, 7. Sauber 57, 8. Scuderia Toro Rosso 33, 9. Williams 5


Saturday, 22 June 2013

Testgate - Mercedes lucky to escape severe sanctions

By Simon Wright

The French capital of Paris has recently played host to an international tribunal which could have had major implications on the Formula One season for 2013.

The FIA tribunal virtually cleared Mercedes in 'Testgate'
Petronas AMG Mercedes F1, whose factory is based in Brackley, Northamptonshire were in the dock over an alleged illegal tyre test they had conducted with Pirelli just days after the Spanish Grand Prix in May.  The Italian tyre supplier was also told to face the summons at the FIA International Tribunal (logo pictured).

Discussions, defence and remonstrations were held in a highly charged environment on Thursday, so much so that journalists were not allowed to use Twitter to update fans during the evidence that was given.

On Friday, the verdict was handed down.  Mercedes were found in breach of sporting regulations, and were reprimanded along with being banned from competing in the Silverstone Young Drivers’ Test.

However, they escaped a hefty fine, points deductions or even race bans for what seemingly seems to be gaining a blatant advantage.

So, why did the penalty feel like no punishment at all, and where does it leave the FIA, Mercedes and Pirelli as the sport regroups at Silverstone for the British Grand Prix next weekend.

Background
For those not in the knowledge of why it went this far, it all started after a difficult weekend for both Pirelli and Mercedes at the Spanish Grand Prix.  Mercedes suffered from chronic tyre wear, as their cars dropped from the front row lockout they took in qualifying to a very uncompetitive sixth place for Nico Rosberg and 12th for Lewis Hamilton. 

Pirelli themselves were heavily criticised (including by yours truly) for tyres that could barely last three laps around Barcelona before they started graining and delaminating on a couple of occasions, including once in the race for Jean-Eric Vergne.  Afterwards, they wanted to do a tyre test and Mercedes agreed to help them out.

While others teams packed up, Mercedes stayed behind at the Circuit de Catalunya, and did a three-day test with their 2013 drivers in a 2013 car.

News of this broke when Rosberg mentioned the test to world champion Sebastian Vettel at the GPDA meeting in Monaco.

Vettel told his team and as more information came out, Red Bull Racing and Ferrari made a joint protest on the morning of the race around the streets of Monte Carlo, claiming that Mercedes were in breach of the FIA Sporting Regulations, which prohibits in-season testing after the first week in March until the end of the season.

Mercedes claimed they had received permission from the FIA.  Although they claimed to have written documents, the FIA stated this wasn’t the case.  After a stewards meeting after the Monaco Grand Prix, which Rosberg won convincingly for Mercedes, the case was sent to a tribunal on 20 June.

Counter Punch
The teams moved onto Canada, which Red Bull team boss Christian Horner used strong words such as ‘foul’ and even stating Mercedes were guilty of a ‘crime.’  It later turned out Ferrari had done their own tyre test after April’s Bahrain Grand Prix, though this was with a 2011 car and thus were cleared of any wrongdoing.

In public, Horner kept suggesting all they wanted was clarity on the whole situation.  Deep down, his body language suggested he wanted a big penalty applied against one of his team’s major rivals.

Other teams kept quiet.  Lotus were lobbied by Red Bull to join the protest, but refused as they had been unhappy with earlier instances regarding technical decisions in the past year.  

McLaren stayed out of the mess, as they have their own problems sorting out a car that is so bad, Jenson Button and Sergio Perez would probably do better performing in a barbershop quartet!

So the evidence started to unravel at the tribunal hearing.  Mercedes claimed that they had gained no benefit from doing the 1,000km test, and team principal Ross Brawn stated they had verbal permission from regular FIA race director Charlie Whiting to use their 2013 car.

They did admit that by using plain helmets to discard the use of race drivers was the wrong thing to do, and apologised for that and clearly stated that the test was at Pirelli’s request, and it was to solve concerns over tyre safety which have dogged this championship.

The FIA’s response was they had received no written consent from Mercedes to do the test, and were unaware of the situation Pirelli had got themselves into.  Thursday also concluded with Mercedes offering a compromise of being banned for the Young Drivers’ Test to try and negate any potential advantage they had.

Verdict surprise
The general reaction I received from text messages from friends who follow the sport on Friday were one of surprise and disappointment.  Journalists seemed surprised by the leninent action too. 

Most were suspecting of at least a points deduction from the constructors’ championship or even expulsion from that championship for 2013.  This result is perfect for Mercedes – and not only keep Ross Brawn’s integrity intact, it keeps him in a job.

If Mercedes were found guilty, the man who worked so brilliantly with Michael Schumacher throughout his first career, and spearheaded the fairytale Brawn story in 2009 from the ashes of Honda would surely have paid the price at Mercedes.

As reported by BBC Sport, Brawn said: "We have a blemish-free record here and it was very important to Mercedes that the facts of this case were understood.

"It does sometimes strengthen your resolve rather than weaken it but now it's cleared away we can concentrate on the rest of the year,"

In their own statement, the FIA commented: "The FIA wishes that lessons are learnt from this case and from the decision handed down.  To this end, the FIA will make sure, in association with all F1 teams, that its control of the testings' is strengthened." 

No consistency
In the immediate aftermath of the verdict, I thought the whole episode had been a complete waste of everyone’s time and money, and it is not fair for Grand Prix racing.

No matter the reasons of the test, Mercedes used a 2013 car which is strictly against the regulations.  This was even admitted by the tribunal, but the punishment is pretty unfair on the other teams.  Mercedes have done an illegal test – there’s no getting away from it in my view and the book could and well should have been thrown at them.

A race ban was potentially there, although if that was applied – could you have imagined the reaction of the British fans if Hamilton hadn’t been allowed to start his home race next week?  That would have been brave to do in the circumstances, as an appeal would almost certainly have been made.

A fairer penalty would have been a deduction of constructors’ points – at least from the two most recent races after the test, or prohibited to score points in the next three events.  It is a team issue, so the drivers should be cleared and made free to race.

The FIA’s rule-making system is not fair – there is no consistency.  Other penalties such as BAR using fuel as ballast in 2005 and the ‘Spygate’ controversy of 2007 have ended with far more serious penalties.

Mercedes have come out of the whole episode smiling.  Red Bull and Ferrari wanted clarity, and that is something that they haven’t really got I think.  Both seem to have grudgingly accepted the verdict, probably the right thing to do so the fans can concentrate on the racing.

Pirelli's named has been tarnished in F1 2013 and rightly so
As for Pirelli (tyres pictured), they've lost total control of the tyre situation in the sport.  Why they don't have their own test car is bewildering.  They had one last year, with former F1 pilots Lucas di Grassi and Jaime Alguersuari doing tyre testing.  Why have they not got one this year?  No matter if it is a financial problem, this is their mess and Formula One is in a difficult place.

With Bridgestone not willing to supply tyres again until the recession ends, and Goodyear and Continental recently stating no interest in a return, the FIA’s determination to hound Michelin out of the sport at the end of 2006 has come back to haunt them.  

We are now stuck with a tyre supplier who might have spiced up the racing, and ensured pitstop strategy is a factor again rather than a complete non-event, but has taken things totally to the other extreme.  The scenario is not good.  Pirelli will probably extend their contract, largely because the FIA has no other options and that is their own fault for what they did to Michelin after the tyre fiasco at Indianapolis in 2005, even after Michelin admitted their guilt and did all they could to reimburse disgruntled supporters at the time. 

The International Tribunal was a total waste of everyone’s time.  Mercedes have escaped virtually scot-free from doing something completely prohibited by the current rules, and whilst we can now try to get back to ‘racing,’ although that is a strong word to use in 2013 considering the crazy tyre management we’ve often seen, I get the feeling more questions have been raised by the verdict rather than the answers we were all looking for.

Monday, 14 January 2013

Autosport International Show 2013 – Stars and cars make up for lack of general content

By Simon Wright

The NEC in Birmingham hosted the annual motorsport exhibition, Autosport International from 10 – 13 January 2013. 

I went on Saturday, 12 January, the 10th successive year I have been to the event that often is seen as the official start of the motorsport season.

Last year’s exhibition was the best in the proud history of the show.  12 months on, it was going to be difficult to beat this. 

Ultimately there were many cars for the public to see, and some top motorsport stars, but the lack of general content was noticeable to see.

Stewart leads the star guests
Leading the star guests at Autosport in 2013 was three-time world Formula One champion Sir Jackie Stewart.

The SF1 from 1997 was in attendance - beginning the team now known today as Red Bull
Stewart gave several interviews throughout the weekend, and was also around to promote his own collection of great racing cars.  Features included his three F1 world championship winning machines from 1969, 1971 and 1973, as well as the SF1 – Stewart Grand Prix’s first car in Formula One in 1997, which metamorphosed into Jaguar and lastly, the hugely successful Red Bull venture.

Scotland’s Paul di Resta also made an appearance for the second successive year.  Di Resta had a tough second season in F1 last year, but is ready to improve on his results with Force India, and seemed in good spirits.  He was the only Grand Prix driver to turn up in 2013.

Jake Humphrey was a big attraction, as he prepares for a new career
Outgoing BBC F1 anchor Jake Humphrey was also around, sharing F1 Racing Grid interview duties with Sky Sports F1 HD commentator David Croft.  Humphrey admitted that he found the 2012 season frustrating to watch, especially as the Beeb don’t have the live central contract anymore, and was surprised to hear that Lee McKenzie was overlooked for the presenter gig in 2013.  Jake’s replacement will be the unattractive Suzi Perry – who used to front MotoGP for the channel, but not since 2009.

Johnny Herbert and Anthony Davidson were also guests of honour, representing Sky as it continues to go from strength and strength.  There were also appearances from World Touring Car champion Rob Huff, DTM racer Andy Prialux, reigning BTCC champion Gordon Shedden and TV presenter Steve Rider.

Racing Grid lives upto expectations
The F1 Racing Grid, which has been a real letdown in recent years was a major plus point this year.  There were lengthy and amusing Q&A sessions between the presenters and the hundreds of fans who flocked to the NEC.  Croft, Herbert and Davidson played a version of the Sky Sports F1 Buzz Game, and Croft even spotted my nodding when I agreed with Davidson’s viewpoint that Nico Hulkenberg would have been a better fit at McLaren, rather than Sergio Perez. 

Testing the reactions with Pirelli was an enthralling experience
Grand Prix tyre supplier Pirelli was back, and allowed fans to test their instant and lightning reactions with the ‘Reactor Game.’  Each person taking part would donate £2 to Great Ormond Street Hospital, and had 30 seconds to see how many times they could press a variety of buttons that flashed up on the stand.  I did this three times, and got a high score of 33 – which was an excellent effort.  I have to say, I got very competitive and felt the high adrenaline buzz from taking part.

There were some flashy road cars from the likes of McLaren and Porsche at the show, along with plenty of go-kart and touring car models, plus a lovely tribute to former World Rally champion Richard Burns.

The tribute of cars to the late Richard Burns was the main highlight
Burns display was main highlight
Burns won the WRC title for Subaru in 2001, but sadly lost his fight against cancer in 2005, after being forced to retire from the sport due to ill health.  Some of Richard’s famous cars were in attendance, including his British Rally entries, the Subaru he drove to the title in 2001, and the Peugeot 206 with which he was leading the 2003 title race until his health declined. 

It was a popular part of this year’s exhibition and is a sad reminder of rallying’s fall from grace.  Both Burns and Colin McRae are no longer with us – the last two World Rally British champions – whilst Sebastian Loeb’s decision to walkaway might end his domination over the past decade, but means there is a severe lack of quality in the 2013 championship.

The Live Action Arena didn’t disappoint either.  Louise Goodman and some bald guy (his name is not familiar!) were the hosts for the usual thrills and spills.  Stunt driver Terry Grant put on another tremendous show with his own tribute to James Bond.  The McLaren Autosport nominees were in attendance, and there was a good luck message from the Road2Recovery rally team, who were involved in a tragic accident on the Dakar Rally last week. 

'Leave me alone, I know what I'm doing!' - Classic Kimi
Not enough choice
Unlike last year though, it seemed like the amount of space had been condensed and there wasn’t as much to see.  There was a lack of book and DVD stalls, so if you wanted to take something away as a souvenir, clothing was your best bet.  I think I made the right decision to buy a black Kimi Raikkonen top, with his famous radio message from Abu Dhabi last year painted in the gold Lotus colours.  ‘Leave me alone, I know what I’m doing’ really does get the message across.

Many manufacturers were missing too.  The powerhouses from Japan, France and Germany were conspicuous by their absence.  Although Britain is in the midst of some freezing temperatures and snow at the moment, it would have been nice from a fan’s perspective to see more choice.  

The economic recession is probably the main factor though.  Many businesses are struggling after Christmas, and notable names like DUKE video were missing this year – suggesting they couldn’t afford to make it to Birmingham in 2013.

All in all – 2013 was a good and entertaining exhibition, but it struggled to match the success of 2012.  That probably won’t stop me though from making the annual pilgrimage again to Autosport International in 2014.